sperry |
2009-04-06 09:19 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by MattR
(Post 131603)
I disagree with the decision...The F1 championship is not choosing winners with a limit on usage...Our fantasy league limits the times you can pick a driver. So today my winning pick is worth half while someone who picks the same winner down the road gets full credit. If there wasn't a restriction on the number of times you could choose a driver, it wouldn't matter. So today, someone who picked poorly gets rewarded.
|
I understand what you're saying, and you're correct picking the winner in Malaysia is similar to picking only 4th place in a race that goes the distance. But the rules for fantasy point scoring is not "10 for picking the winner, etc...", it's "share the points awarded by the FIA". Even if it potentially screws w/ those of us that picked well for this round, I can't in good conscience award full points unless there was some technical reason why the website couldn't be made to score it properly.
I really don't want to go down the road where we're second guessing the official results... for example, if someone is excluded from championship points, that will be reflected in our points... otherwise, technically Hamilton crossed the line 4th in Australia, but we're not going to score fantasy points for Hamilton in 4th because we might disagree with his later exclusion, right? Similarly, if Malaysia is only worth half points, then that's just tough luck for those of us that picked Button (assuming Button goes on to win 9 more times this season and we miss out on a 10 point win we could have scored if not for the 5 point win we picked in Malaysia). At the end of the season, the driver's point totals in our result should exactly match the official FIA point totals.
All in all, I don't think it's all that different from picking a good driver that ends up getting hit from behind, or is otherwise taken out of the race to no fault of his own. Sometimes events are out of our control, and a good pick nets nothing. Personally, I"ll take those 5 points for Button, because I think by the end of the season, Ferrari and McLaren are going to be back up at the top of the results, and I'll be glad I got those early Brawn points before they're back to being mid-packers. :(
But you do have a good argument that I'm not trying to dismiss offhand or anything. Picking poorly this past round could certainly work to your advantage later in the season. Some people may have lucked out, and some of us are getting the bad luck balance. I just think that in this situation, the most fair action is to stick to the letter of the way the rules were written. If we had awarded full points for the round, those on the other side of the coin would have a more valid (IMO) argument that we weren't sticking to the rules.
|