My old AVS ES100's (which were my least favorite tire ever btw) are 215/45/17. Subydude talked me out of 225/45/17 saying they'd rub. Which is ironic considering he tried to sell me 17X9 wheels recently.
Let me know if you want me to save you any of them.
I can see that you're a little bit black and white about things and that's fine. But the M+S rating on the Generals has to be good for something even if the reviews claiming they work decent in snow aren't. If you think they're a poor fit given my criteria above your last post, please let me know what you think is a better fit and why.
Also, it sounds like I haven't made it clear that I want a tire that lasts and is a good fit. I'm looking for a good investment over the long haul.