So Amanda remembered that it was Monday night that she left the garage door open. She feels really bad but we've both left it open accidentally. At least we didn't lose much. They also stole Amanda's CD's, none of which were backed up.
I actually remember that Lucy started barking at like 10 or 11pm but I just told her to shutup.
What's really crazy is that my new snowboard and bindings (and my snowboard boots) were inside my unlocked car in the garage. Apparently it's a $4-500 snowboard. I just bought it (for $150) from the Mogul Mouse ski swap but the bindings that I had also bought were a touch small so I put it all in the car to replace the bindings the next day.
There were some other valuable things that were left alone too. Looks like they just grabbed a couple easy obvious things and jammed.