Just park that anywhere, like in the dirt off of turn 12

[sperry]

Went out to RFR today... the motor break-in is going well... too bad I can't say the same for the suspension.

I was braking into the horseshoe today when the left-front control arm failed. Left front tire immediately turned 90deg right and slammed into the fender locking it up. I went of in a straight line right up and off the turn. Had to hitch a ride back to Reno from a nice guy named Dimitri with a nice EVO to pick up the truck and trailer (figures the one time I don't trailer to the track, the car breaks). MikeK came back out with me to winch the car up off the track where Danny had dragged it with the ATV. It was a hassle, but we got it back to Reno.

So, the damage: it looks like the stamped steel control arm that comes on the WRX (as opposed to the lighter aluminum ones the STi's have) failed... tore straight in half (probably along the weld?). The front swaybar and LF endlink are toast. And worst of all, I'll bet the LF strut is probably busted, which is probably going to be a nightmare to find a replacement for under $1500 since those Tein SuperRace coilover were oh-so-unpopular. The LF fender is mangled, but it was the one with all the fence damage on it already, so no big loss there. And I'm sure there are several other bits and pieces that are kaput (like the tie-rods and maybe the ball joint... and who knows how well the bearings will handle the sudden force of the tire jamming against the fender). At least the brakes seem okay, and the wheel is undamaged, though the rubbing on the tire may have rendered it untrackable, but it was a 2 year old 615.

But more importantly, here's what I learned: Earlier in the day in the 1st session out, I noticed the car seemed to pull to the right under hard braking at the end of the front straight. I even mentioned it to Jim Kunze who was out there today. So I pulled off immediately and put the car up on jack stands to inspect everything under there. I couldn't find anything wrong with the inspection, and the steering rack and everything related seemed fine and tight. And before heading back out, I took a few laps around the paddock and really tossed the steering back and forth and things all seemed okay. Then on the second session, I didn't really feel anything weird, but I wasn't braking as hard since I was just trying to settle into a rhythm to putt around putting miles on the car, but that session was cut short when a boost hose popped off at all of about 10psi of boost. Then in the third session, without warning and under light braking, kerblammo. I can only guess there was a crack in the control arm that was allowing it to flex and causing the bump steer I was noticing under braking... then after coming over the bumpy part of the track leading to the horseshoe, it finally cracked enough that the light braking I did finished the job. But what I learned was: when something feels out of place, figure it out... don't get back in the car until you're sure you sorted it out. I was very lucky the failure happened at relatively low speed on a race track with run-off instead of at 80mph on the freeway on the way home.

Anyway, MikeK brought his camera out to document my misery... he'll probably post up some picks of the carnage. My question is (most to Cory since I'm sure he's dealt with cars at his show that come in during the winter after hitting curbs), how the hell do you move these things!? Mike and I just dragged the car up onto my trailer w/ the winch, but I'm not sure I know how to get it off, let alone up my driveway and into the garage so I can work on it. I guess I need some sort of wheel dolly... where do I get one? Summit? Harbor Freight?

Any suggestions you guys have, I'm all ears.

[Tahoe C5]

What a drag... literally! You're right, we need to use all our senses to moniter any changes in a car. Especially when we subject them to more stresses than normal sane people. I'll bet the bearings are fine. Harbor freight has wheel dolleys pretty cheap, I saw them there on Friday.

Glad you're OK

[100_Percent_Juice]

This could work. http://store.summitracing.com/partde...5&autoview=sku Harbor freight would obviously be cheaper though.
What are the plans for the car now?

[Dean]

I'm glad you are OK and it didn't happen at the end of any of the long straights. That could have been ugly.

Since it is only 1 corner, you might be able to use one or more floor jacks and some helpers to move it around. let us know if you need help.

None of the cheap car dollies are designed to handle much other than flat surfaces. Going up a driveway may be challenging depending on the surface transitions.

Yes harbor freight has them. A furniture dolly with a cradle or some plywood on it might work as well. You can also take off the wheel and put some fat people in the trunk and right back seat to help.

Non-lifting:
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=32052
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=93368
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=38959
lifting:
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=94682

[100_Percent_Juice]

This way will only cost you like $20 and you don't need to invite your fat friends to eat all your food.

[sperry]

The bigger problem is getting the car down off the trailer. A set of dollies would be pretty easy for moving it around in the garage... and perhaps even up the driveway, though it'd take a bit of muscle... but I don't know that they'll be any use at all getting the car down and off the trailer. We were only able to get it on there by dragging it up with the winch... I don't have a way to drag it off the trailer.

[Nick Koan]

That freaking blows man

[Dean]

Originally Posted by sperry

The bigger problem is getting the car down off the trailer.

Can you strip some to all of that corner while it is on the trailer just leaving a brake caliper with a block of wood strapped into it hanging from the empty strut top hole? Or at least get the wheel off?

If so, then unhook the winch (Which pulls down as well as forward) and use
man weight and the e-brake to back it off.

I think with you and 2-4 people and a couple floor jacks, we can put it wherever you want.

I assume it still runs, so as long as the front left shaft (or lack there of if you pull it) can turn freely, you can start it and "drive" it. very slowly...

Cars in much worse shape have been moved with floor jacks. You may have to keep moving them and switching pick up points, but big deal.

[MikeK]

At least the steering wheel looks straight ...

[Dean]

That's not bad... pull that wheel and rotor and lets move that pig...

[sperry]

Since this isn't really about my engine anymore, I split it into its own thread...

I pulled the wheel off, the damage doesn't look all that terrible. The failure was indeed along the welds on the LCA... when it broke, it allowed the wheel to travel towards the rear and outside of the car and impact the fender. The steering tie rod is what turned the wheel right as the back pulled away. Because the tire jammed up into the wheel well, it appears that with the exception of the swaybar and endlink, none of the suspension components exceeded their normal range of movement. The strut looks straight and healthy, the hub looks okay, even the flimsy tie rod looks unbent. The axle is suspect... it pulled out of the transmission, so I'm not sure if the CVs were damaged or not before things came loose.








But back to the matter at hand: getting this pile off my trailer. I pulled the brake rotor and blocked the caliper (so I can still use the brakes on the 3 good corners). Was hoping to just drive the thing right off, but when I attempted to let the jack down, it was obvious that the car is going to lay the frame down on the ground. So, I need a dolly or a wood skid... something to keep the corner off the ground, and able to get down the trailer ramps.

It anyone off work now? Feel like coming over and helping drag a car off a trailer?

[JonnydaJibba]

Did anyone come over to help? If you can't get it moved today I can help out tomorrow. Today I have to finish my axle/hub/bearing/ball joint/front break job. Unfortunately I only have one means of transportation. Keep us posted.

[MikeK]

I there any chance you can just repair it on the trailer?

[MattR]

You need a pallet jack.

[MattR]

Or an 8' long 4x4 so it can slide down to the ground.

[AtomicLabMonkey]

Originally Posted by MikeK

I there any chance you can just repair it on the trailer?

If you can get the LBJ out of the spindle, I'd just do that. Call around to junkyards & get a replacement LCA to throw on there so you can drive it off. If you put a dolly on that corner you don't know what's gonna happen as you're moving it off the trailer, up the driveway, & into the garage.. it could slip off and damage something else.

And, . That sucks, dude. If it ain't one thing, it's tha motherfuckin' other.

[sperry]

Welp, Dean took off just now after coming over to help. We used a small 1000 lb rated furniture dolly, my big old Craftsman jack and some planks of wood to roll the bitch off the trailer.

Started with the trailer winch looped around the ass-end of the trailer and hooked to the front of the car to pull it until the rear tires were on the ground, then muscled it the rest of the way by hand from there. It was a PITA, but not terribly so. Big thanks to Dean for the help. Only took us about 90 minutes, and that includes time to park the trailer in the backyard, bullshit a bit, and eat some homemade chocolate chip cookies.

Now all I need to do it pull off the potentially busted parts and figure out what needs replacing so I can order up some parts. Anyone know a good place to pick up some '04-'06 USDM STi aluminum LCA's? They're the same as the JDM Spec-C ones that gain you 1.5 deg of static caster. I'll also need a new front swaybar... I'll probably just get another 20-22mm Whiteline one... as that seems to work well with my existing suspension setup. And some new endlinks for sure. Hopefully the axle's alright, and nothing else is bent... especially in the steering rack, since I just finished rebuilding that bitch right before all this happened.

[Dean]

The front tie down on the Impreza is great for this sort of thing. It is slightly pointy and sticks down below the sub frame so it drops right into the "cup" of old clunky floor jacks. you can even sort of steer it...

We balanced the load between that and a 2x6 spanning the mini dolly under the entire left front sub frame with the sub frame bolt heads cutting into the wood.

Worked great.

And you are welcome... Yummy cookies...

[MattR]

Nice work guys..

Also, I think turn 12 at RFR should be called the "Sperry Corner", given your history there.

[sperry]

Originally Posted by MattR

Nice work guys..

Also, I think turn 12 at RFR should be called the "Sperry Corner", given your history there.

Well, I didn't go off there this time... I went off the back of the horseshoe. The exit of old turn 12 is just where Danny and I dragged the car to get it out of the way of the hot track so they could get the sessions back up and running.

[MattR]

Oh.

[ScottyS]

Man, what a PITA. That's probably not something that happens every day.

[Shoobie]

Oh, tough luck Scott. Hope to see it moving again soon, hopefully without a lot of expensive new parts.

[MPREZIV]

That blows. That's all I've got...

[sperry]

I got around to pulling some parts off...

Yanked the busted control arm... it was impossible to pull the ball-joint w/o damaging it, so once the pickle-fork trashed the rubber boot, I just took it off at the knuckle side and left the BJ on the half of a control arm. Looks like I'll need to order a second Whiteline roll-center kit for a new extended ball-joint.

I also noticed that the subframe where the front mounting point for the LCA has cracked welds. So I also need to find someone with a welder and some skill to help me out. I've never welded and don't have the equipment, so buying a welder and attempting to learn for something as critical as the car's suspension isn't really something I want to do. Is anyone with a 110V welder (or a 30 ft long 220V extension cord, I can unhook the dryer I guess ) free this weekend?

I got a closer look at the strut. It's not off the car, but it's unhooked from the knuckle. There's a little less throw that I thought on the upper pillowball, but I still think there was enough to have kept it from getting damaged. But I'm not willing to call the strut "okay" just yet.